The image depicted here is probably the sort of thing that many people picture when they think of the first Thanksgiving. I remember images like this pinned to bulletin boards in my elementary school classrooms and it has stuck with me. There is a lot about it that is inaccurate–more on that in a moment. But there was a gathering in 1621 that looked at least a bit like this. We all know this event took place in Plymouth, Massachusetts. But did you ever wonder where, specifically, this scene played out? For people visiting Plymouth during the holiday, it might be of interest to know where the first “Thanksgiving” took place.
Before we get to where, a little bit about the image itself and what actually happened that fall in 1621. The painting was done around 1912 by artist Jean Leon Gerome Ferris. Ferris was born in Philadelphia in 1863. He produced this painting as part of a series of 78 depictions of important moments in American history which he called “The Pagent of a Nation,” the largest such compilation of artwork.
There are several inaccuracies. Before getting to some specific details, I think the general atmosphere of joviality may be a little off. Of course it’s difficult to say. Winslow does say there feasting and games. But the 19th century penchant for depicting this event as purely easygoing merriment tend to belie the real tensions between these two group. And the fact that the Native Americans had encountered European slavers and experienced devastating losses due to new diseases brought by European explorers tends to be overshadowed by images like this. That’s certainly something that must be kept in mind. I’ve always felt the actual first Thanksgiving must have had an undercurrent of tension.
As for some of the details, it’s problematic that Ferris depicted the Native Americans in the garb of the Plains tribes. This was a common error in artwork of the time…people were more familiar with the Plains tribes than they were with the eastern woodland Native Americans of centuries earlier. The Wampanoag who participated in the first Thanksgiving dressed differently and did not wear the stereotypical feathered headdresses. Also, there really ought to be more Native Americans. According to Winslow’s account, there were about 90 Wampanoag and roughly 50 English at the celebration.
The house in the background isn’t quite right (they probably did not have stone chimneys and the exteriors were most likely shingled). The thatched roof is likely correct and its construction as depicted is certainly better than the log cabins shown in most artwork of that era. The Pilgrims did not build log cabins.
That said, there are some clever details in the painting that show that Ferris did his research. The fellow standing at far right is Edward Winslow. There exists a painting of Edward Winslow, the only known portrait of one of the Pilgrims. Ferris copied Winslow’s face and put it in his Thanksgiving depiction. The Winslow portrait was done 30 years after the first Thanksgiving, so Winslow ought to appear rather younger, but still, it’s a nice touch. The presence of the spaniel shows that Ferris read William Bradford’s journal. Bradford mentions that a spaniel and mastiff were brought on the Mayflower. And the clothing of the English settlers is generally accurate…much better than the black suits, white napkins and buckled hats that somehow worked their way into most depictions of Pilgrims during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
Edward Winslow wrote letters to associates back in England, some of which were compiled and published in 1622 as Mourt’s Relation (so called because the publisher in London was a George Morton, sometimes known as George Mourt). It was, essentially, a publicity piece meant to attract more colonists to Plymouth. Winslow’s description of the first Thanksgiving in 1621 is the best primary source available on the subject (Bradford wrote about it as well, and his paragraph is also an valuable source, but written many years after the fact). As Winslow describes it:
Our harvest being gotten in, our governor sent four men on fowling, that so we might after a special manner rejoice together after we had gathered the fruit of our labors. They four in one day killed as much fowl as, with a little help beside, served the company almost a week. At which time, among other recreations, we exercised our arms, many of the Indians coming amongst us, and among the rest their greatest king Massasoit, with some ninety men, whom for three days we entertained and feasted, and they went out and killed five deer, which they brought to the plantation and bestowed upon our governor, and upon the captain, and others. And although it be not always so plentiful as it was at this time with us, yet by the goodness of God, we are so far from want that we often wish you partakers of our plenty.
They did not call it a “thanksgiving.” That term was in their vocabulary but such events were religious observances–days of prayer and fasting. What took place in the fall of 1621 was a celebration on the part of the English settlers that they had survived their first year and managed, with the help of the Wampanoag, to raise a successful harvest. It was probably inspired by the traditional English harvest festivals rather than any religious tradition. The exact month is not mentioned but the event likely took place in September 1621. With roughly 140 participants, this was no small celebration. There was no one table around which they all gathered, as shown in some depictions. And it took place over the course of three days with hunting, feasting, military drills and games.
So, when you consider where this all took place, given the size of the celebration, it likely happened all throughout the village of Plymouth. The first street built by the English settlers, along which they constructed their primitive houses, is now known as Leyden Street in downtown Plymouth. At the head of Leyden Street is Town Square. This is the street recreated at the living history museum, Plimoth Plantation, as it appeared in the 1620s.
There was a town common of sorts in 1621. It was a space left open between John Alden’s house and William Bradford’s house where the militia could drill. The location is now occupied by the Bradford Building at the corner of Town Square and Main Street. This open space would have been a convenient place for an outdoor feast and games.
I have always thought of that spot as the epicenter of Thanksgiving although there is probably no single spot that you can point to. It is interesting to look at that block today and to try to imagine the festivities that took place there nearly 400 years ago–an event remembered by virtually the entire nation once a year.
November 25th, 2010 at 3:08 pm
Great article to read when I woke up on this Thanksgiving day . Thank you Patrick. Jordie
November 22nd, 2013 at 8:27 am
Reblogged this on Historical Digression.
November 30th, 2013 at 6:42 pm
Thanks Patrick. Have you read Mayflower by Nathaniel Philbrick? Fascinating detail, from England to the Atlantic Ocean to Provincetown (as it would become called) to Plymouth.
December 1st, 2013 at 8:59 am
I have Jim, and refer to it often. Excellent book.
November 19th, 2017 at 8:10 pm
[…] 3. Analyze the Painting by JLG Ferris, 1912 to determine inaccuracies of the real first Thanksgiving CLICK HERE Where First Thanksgiving Took Place […]
October 3rd, 2021 at 3:59 pm
Thank you for sharinng