Oddly enough, as I’ve been doing a good amount of research on the Peninsular Campaign lately, I keep coming across the name of this vessel…the Elm City. Again and again, I find it mentioned in far flung sources, various regimental histories, Sanitary Commission letters, even a journal in the collection of the historical society where I work.
Her significance might at first seem trivial, but it seems this ship was all over the place during the Peninsular Campaign, transporting thousands of men, bringing them towards the front and then bringing the sick and wounded away from the Peninsula back to safety. As one of the larger steamships involved in the transport effort, she had a significant impact on the campaign and, I think, deserves a little attention. And so, I present here a sampling of excerpts from various sources, a patchwork which might provide a sense of the extensive service of the Elm City.
First, her origins…The Elm City was built in 1855 in New York for the passenger line between New York and New Haven. The latter place has long had the nickname, “the city of elms,” hence the name of the vessel. She was 300 feet long and designed to accommodate 350 passengers. She was commanded by Capt. J.M. Lewis. I find reference to Lewis still being in charge as of 1861 and I wonder if he remained in command when she was brought into army service. It seems likely to me that he did, but I do not know.
A prelude to her duty during the Peninsular Campaign was her occasional service, during 1861, in bringing new regiments towards the seat of war. The 6th Connecticut Infantry, for instance, in September 1861, was brought from New Haven to Jersey City on their way to Washington. Sgt. Charles Caldwell later wrote, “Handkerchiefs from the fair ones bid us adieu…together with the martial music from the band to increase enthusiasm made our departure from New Haven pleasant to contemplate…We embarked on the steamer Elm City and soon stretched ourselves on the several decks and in the cabin, glad enough for a chance to rest ourselves…”
At some point early in 1862 (I wish I knew when) the Elm City was placed under the control of the U.S. Army Quartermaster’s Department. General McClellan’s Peninsular Campaign got underway in March 1862 and the Elm City became one of the key transport ships bringing the Army of the Potomac down to Fortress Monroe, the staging point for the campaign.
Among the first units she transported in this campaign were the 3rd and 4th Maine Infantry regiments which embarked at Alexandria. Finally on the move, the men of the Army of the Potomac were full of excitement. Frederick Floyd of the 40th New York Infantry observed the great flotilla at Alexandria, noted the Elm City pass by, and later wrote, “On shore all was bustle and activity, and the numerous steamboats in the river made the scene very animating. The bands played patriotic tunes and the men cheered… It was a beautiful day, with the sun shining in all its magnificent effulgence, betokening a pleasant voyage to our destination, which we now knew to be Fort Monroe.”
On March 21, the Elm City transported the 18th Massachusetts Infantry from Alexandria to Fortress Monroe. During late March and early April, the vessel must have been going constantly to and fro, feeding new regiments into the campaign.
On April 3, Brigadier General Dan Sickles embarked on the Elm City at Liverpool Point, Maryland. A man eternally embroiled in controversy, Sickles had just discovered that Congress had refused to confirm his commission as Brigadier General and his command of the Excelsior Brigade had been revoked. While on board the Elm City, Sickles penned an angry protest to his superior officer, General Joseph Hooker and wrote a farewell letter to his brigade. “…After a year of service with you, it is hard to yield to the necessity which separates me from so many brave and devoted companions-in-arms…White protesting that it is unlawful and unjust, I obey this command, because obedience to superior authority is the first duty of a soldier…” After months of protest, Sickles’s commission and brigade command would be restored in May.
The 72nd New York Infantry was with Sickles on board the Elm City. When they reached Hampton Roads, the Elm City came alongside the famous Monitor and the men examined the ship with great interest. As they watched, the Confederate ironclad Virginia appeared, maneuvering for battle, trying to goad the Monitor into another fight. The Monitor did not take the bait and the men on board the Elm City were rather disappointed.
On April 17, the Elm City transported General Philip Kearny and his New Jersey Brigade from the Potomac River to the Union trenches near Yorktown. The fiery Kearny, famous for his insubordinate outbursts, was eager to get into the fight (which at the time, with the Army of the Potomac entrenched outside Yorktown, wasn’t much of a fight). Kearny fumed as McClellan forced his brigade to remain on board the Elm City for days. Francis Colburn Adams of the 1st New York Cavalry later wrote, “The general’s impatience at being kept afloat in this manner found expression every day in language more emphatic than the rules of services warranted.”
After Yorktown was finally taken, the Elm City was busy transporting regiments from Yorktown to West Point Landing at the mouth of the Pamunkey River. These included the 22nd Massachusetts Infantry on May 8. Although the 22nd’s ride up the York River on the Elm City lasted only three hours, they were very glad for the rest after waiting a day in the streets of Yorktown in the rain for their turn to embark.
The Elm City’s most remarkable service began in mid-May when she was transferred to the United States Sanitary Commission. This revolutionary organization employed a large network of civilians, male and female, whose objective it was to support the Army Medical Bureau. One of the Sanitary Commission’s most remarkable projects was the outfitting of hospital transport ships to bring wounded men from the Peninsula to hospitals in Washington, Philadelphia, New York and elsewhere. The Elm City became one of these ships. It is sadly ironic that a vessel built for pleasure cruises would now be transporting men shattered by battle.
On May 14, the Elm City was loaded up with 440 wounded men and departed for Washington. One of the Sanitary Commission nurses, Katherine Wormeley, wrote with high praise of one of the nurses on board the Elm City, “Mrs. Griffin is magnificent at that. I never saw her hurried or worried for a moment…She spent this morning on the Elm City watching over three men until they died, receiving their last wishes, which she is now writing to their wives.”
On June 27, after an untold number of voyages transporting the wounded, the Elm City was off of White House Landing. The place was, during most of the Peninsular Campaign, the main base of supplies for the Army of the Potomac. Previously a backwater, it had been transformed into a bustling river port. But on June 27, that all changed. On that day, with the Union defeat at Gaines Mill, General McClellan made the decision to abandon White House Landing and change his base to Harrison Landing on the James River. Everything at White House Landing was thrown into panic and chaos.
Katherine Wormeley wrote, “…General Porter, being flanked in immense force, has wheeled round and back…The whole army is now across [the Chickahominy] river; the enemy are in part on this side of it…The enemy evidently hope to ruin us by seizing this station…everything has been sent away; the few things that remain are lying on the wharves…The Elm City is waiting for the 93rd New York Regiment, which is stationed here on guard duty…even as I write comes the order to start, the enemy having got the railroad. And so rapidly have we gone, that between writing the words “Elm City” and “railroad” we are off! Such a jolly panic! Men rushing and tearing down to the wharves…The enemy are in force three miles from us; they have seized the railroad, and cut the telegraph.”
After this narrow scrape, the Elm City continued in service with the Sanitary Commission until the U.S. Army took control of the hospital ships. As the Peninsular Campaign came to a fruitless close, the Elm City was employed in transporting regiments off of the Peninsula and to Northern Virginia where a new campaign was commenced in August.
I wish I could say how many soldiers were transported aboard this hard-working steamship. The number must be in the tens of thousands. And how many lives were saved on her decks when she served as a hospital ship, we will likely never know. But certainly, the Elm City rendered tremendous service and played a significant role during the campaign.
July 29th, 2012 at 11:19 am
What an interesting story. I had to hunt around to find what became of her (strange there isn’t a Wikipedia page for the Elm City). It appears she was wrecked in fog in 1873 under a Captain Frederick Peck. Peck had commanded the ship for the last three years, according to the New York Times.
July 29th, 2012 at 11:58 am
J.G., I agree that she ought to be a bit better known. As for the wreck, I wonder if she was actually repaired. I found later references to an “Elm City” but I’m not sure if it is the same vessel.
November 27th, 2012 at 3:58 pm
All day Saturday excursions on the steamship Elm City in the late 1870’s were operated by my great grandfather, Edward Shadgett Barber and his partner, J. Miles Peck, of the New Haven Steamship Company. The captain was John E. Bowns. These excursions ran from the Sheffield Dock in New Haven to various points around the Sound. There were about 500 people on board for these daily cruises complete with waited food and beverage (probably lemonade), dancing and brass bands. The trips were well advertised and people would take the train from various towns around Connecticut and Massachusetts in the morning and then would return home by train that night. The total average cost of the excursion was $1,000 and the fares ran from $1.75 to $2.75 per person including train fare.
The Elm City also ran daily weekday service between New Haven and New York.
I have pictures and newspaper articles about these excursions if anyone is interested in having copies. Just email me.
The Elm City was eventually wrecked and was never recovered.
James Edward Barber
November 27th, 2012 at 4:20 pm
Now that’s a small world! So glad you found this post and thanks for sharing that history!
June 12th, 2013 at 12:44 pm
Does anyone have information where the Elm City wrecked. We believe the remains are in Walkerton, VA on the Mattaponi river. We have a wreck here that still has the boiler visible at low tide.
Write me email@example.com
May 20th, 2014 at 8:36 pm
My Grandfather’s small fishing boat was hit and sunk by the Elm City in the around New York late one night. My Grandfather was killed and a young man and older man were saved. He was bringing a load fish to market. I believe it was around Hells Kitchen area. If anyone wants more detail let me know. My sister has newspaper obituary. He left many kids without a father in Whitestone NY.
May 21st, 2014 at 6:24 am
A sad story. I looked into this a bit and found the following article in the New York Times, http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?res=F00A12FD3B59157493CAAB1783D85F418584F9 . It mentions that James Lester, Richard Roberts and Joseph Stratton drowned in the collision in 1855. Was one of those your ancestor?
September 8th, 2019 at 7:06 pm
I was just admiring the monument to Captain J. Miles Lewis (d. 1864) in the Grove Street Cemetery in New Haven, which includes two images of steamship(s). The Elm City? I have a photo I can share.
December 10th, 2021 at 3:32 pm
I read with great interest the exploits of the Steamship Elm City during the Peninsula campaign. According to “Leading Families of the City of Baltimore -1897” shortly after the beginning of the Civil War, my great grandfather George Allen Raynor at the age of 23 became Pilot of the Elm City. He served as Pilot on this ship and others through the end of the war including General Butler’s Staff Ship Greyhound and one of General Grant’s Ships during the last year of the war. After the war he became master of several different steamships (mostly the Helen and the Eastern Shore) sailing between Norfolk, Baltimore and Delmarva’s Eastern Shore until retiring in 1913. Thank you for enlightening me about the Civil War service of the Elm City.